startrek vs starwars

by Admiral Vortar 2008-02-18, 00:02

witch one do you think would win

by Jtull 2008-02-18, 00:05

star trek.

by paulwall99 2008-02-18, 00:05

star trek would kill them like all star wars has are fighters

by Philly Homer 2008-02-18, 00:13

Umm... no... do you know how big the Star Wars ships are? Even an Imperial Class Star Destroyer can dwarf a Galaxy class... Plus, ST shielding sucks.

by Admiral Vortar 2008-02-18, 00:14

poor starwars

by Philly Homer 2008-02-18, 00:25

Meh, all a matter of personal preference. Just like Windows vs. Macs. I just go by my philosophy that, "Star Trek is insignificant to the power of the Force."

by Jtull 2008-02-18, 00:26

kinda but the borg could assimilate the empire easily.

by Admiral Vortar 2008-02-18, 00:29

yes then take the galaxy for themselves

by Philly Homer 2008-02-18, 00:29

...I would think...

Eclipse>Borg combined fleet.

Fin.

by Jtull 2008-02-18, 00:30

a complete borg fleet would be enuf to destory a entire quadrent.

by Philly Homer 2008-02-18, 00:31

Like I said, anything ST is insignificant to the power of the Force.

by Jtull 2008-02-18, 00:33

yea but some how I think the borg would master the force quickly to make them more "perfect".

by Philly Homer 2008-02-18, 01:05

...The Borg can't adapt to lightsabers, now can they? Even if you only had two Jedi padawans, they could kill off every single Borg on board a cube in less than two hours. Plus, you can't just magically gain Force powers. You have to be born with them.

EDIT- However, if we're just talking about technology, ST would still lose.

Need proof?

http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Tech/
http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Tactics/

by Shemuel 2008-02-18, 17:27

Anyway, if there were that many Borg they would have taken over everything in the quadrant already.

by raffitz 2008-02-18, 18:55

However, if the Borg assimilated jedi or sith guys, they would acquire the knowledge to defeat the empire! Very Happy

by Shemuel 2008-02-18, 19:07

But they still wouldn't be able to do it.

by Philly Homer 2008-02-18, 19:16

And you think that would happen? Any competent Jedi/Sith would not be so stupid as to be assimilated by Borg... Plus, who says Star Wars=Empire only? Anyways, Borg cube=1kmx1kmx1km. SSD= 18km length alone... Plus a huge load of heavy turbolasers.

by Darkjedi 2008-02-19, 15:08

As Darkjedi, I have to agree with Alkanosis. Nothing can compare to the power of the force!
Watch:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hNxhrPaaCA4

by Philly Homer 2008-02-19, 19:08

Anyways, propulsion... Star Wars hyperdrive systems can enable ships to traverse entire galaxies in a matter of seconds. The best propulsion systems that we see in Star Trek are the Borg, but they have to use a large hub that isn't even 1/10 as good as the Star Wars propulsion systems.

As for communication, well... You can find that out in the two links that I've posted.

So anyways, final chart...

Weaponry- Star Wars wins
Shielding- Star Wars wins
Propulsion- Star Wars wins
Comm systems- Star Wars wins
Most plot devices- Star Trek
Most inconsistencies- Star Trek
Longest running- Star Trek (duh.)

by Jtull 2008-02-20, 00:29

well the borg would just adapt and figure out how to beat the empire.

by Darkjedi 2008-02-20, 15:43

Did anyone watch the video?

by Shemuel 2008-02-20, 17:06

Yeah, But never in a million years would that happen
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDTHB4sSKAI&feature=related

by Philly Homer 2008-02-20, 17:53

Jtull wrote:well the borg would just adapt and figure out how to beat the empire.

Who says Star Trek=Borg and Star Wars=Empire?

by Darkjedi 2008-02-22, 02:39

Yeah?

by Shemuel 2008-02-22, 16:18

Beacause star wars would almost certainly be Empire as apart from the ventilation tube or whatever it was on the death star, nothing would be left of the rebels-and the rebels wouldn't be able to defeat even the Lysians.
Star trek probably means Borg as they are the only ones that have enough unique technology to offbalance the Empire, but my Star trek knowledge is dodgy.

by Philly Homer 2008-02-22, 16:27

Star Trek is full of flaws anyways. How can Voyager (an Intrepic class scout) take on a tactical cube with literally no damage to itself? Oh, and need I mention Threshold? That episode was [Alkanosis-British voice]bollocks[/British voice].

by Shemuel 2008-02-22, 17:15

I've no idea. I have only some Kirk-era star trek, some star trek:next generation, and am watching DS9

by Darkjedi 2008-02-22, 18:52

That's sad.

by Shemuel 2008-02-23, 13:19

Yes, yes it is.

Does anyone else notice how sentimental Star trek can be?

by Philly Homer 2008-02-23, 15:58

It can be quite so at times. I found it somewhat strange that they flirted with each other with technobabble... That's a no-no, I believe...

by mokhrahikim 2008-02-26, 05:32

The Super Stardestroyer has a weakness of some kind.......Destroy that thing-y above the bridge and have a small ship to collide with the bridge..then BOOM! A gigantic ship goes down..... startrek vs starwars Battle1

by Darkjedi 2008-02-26, 14:26

Yea! Wonderful picture!

by Philly Homer 2008-02-26, 19:03

Okay, sure. Just go round up the entire Rebel fleet and go attempt to destroy the Eclipse by itself. Let's see how well that goes...

by mokhrahikim 2008-02-27, 10:12

TO destroy a d**n eclipse stardestroyer call a fleet of Klingons and Romulans.....engage their cloak....tail the eclipse and beam in...if that dont work.....run in huge circles while firing type X phasers. Thats is my strategy in BROKENMIRROR.

by Philly Homer 2008-02-27, 22:55

Dude... the Eclipse would just hyperjump away as soon it was being fired upon. Star Wars hyperdrive systems can traverse entire galaxies in a matter of seconds... Star Trek? Just give 'em about 8 decades to do the same...

by stewi0001 2008-02-27, 23:22

yea and this is kind of a hard place to ask that question since most people here like star trek more.

by Jtull 2008-02-28, 01:17

wat about transwarp.

by mokhrahikim 2008-02-28, 05:06

good one dude

but I can call in a reman warbird and fire at the Eclipse and destroy it while the warbird is cloaked

by Darkjedi 2008-02-28, 12:34

What? You can't fire at people when cloaked! Remember?

by Philly Homer 2008-02-28, 18:59

Technically, the Reman Warbird's cloak is so advanced that the Reman Warbird CAN fire disruptors and torpedoes while cloaked. The main thaleron cannon, however, is a different story. There's only one Reman Warbird anyways and, guess what, it was destroyed by a completely inferior ship- the Sovereign-class battlecruiser. Trek is filled with inconsistencies and plot holes. Star Wars has uber ships of all kinds and therefore doesn't need to be inconsistent. Oh, and also, everything in Star Wars has happened "A long time ago."

by Jtull 2008-02-28, 20:46

but the Stor wars Ships ore crewed by Noobs

by Philly Homer 2008-02-28, 21:42

And Star Trek has incompetent scrubs such as Janeway. Whoop-de-doo.

by Jtull 2008-02-28, 21:50

yea she gets to emotioly envolved in things.

by Darkjedi 2008-02-29, 13:55

That's why she's an incompetent scrub.
(LOL Alkanosis! Good one. "Incompetent Scrub".)

by Jtull 2008-02-29, 17:41

if only they had goten a guy capitain like picard.

by Philly Homer 2008-02-29, 17:45

Kirk is better. But anyways, we're talking about the better side of Star Trek. Captains like Archer, Picard, or Kirk are basically the best Star Trek has to offer. Star Wars is just a bunch of uber technology that would knock all the races in Star Trek out of existence in a matter of days, considering the fact that it happened "a long time ago."

And Jtull, I didn't notice your transwarp post, but again, everything in Star Wars happened a long time ago. Plus, we only know that Starfleet, Borg, and the Voth has transwarp. Anything that has a hyperdrive in Star Wars has that galaxy-crossing capability.

by Jtull 2008-02-29, 17:59

ah but tranzwarp has univerce crossing ability.

by Philly Homer 2008-02-29, 18:07

Incorrect. It still took Voyager a few minutes to cross about 1/5 of a galaxy using the Borg transwarp hub. And please don't reference Threshold, that was the most idiotic episode of the entire Voyager series. That episode makes you think if the writers were thinking at all.

by Shemuel 2008-02-29, 18:56

Who is this "Janeway" you talk of?

by Philly Homer 2008-02-29, 19:08

Oh right I forgot... You guys don't get Star Trek: Voyager yet, right?

by Sponsored content

who do you would win